Asda's Budget Tea Triumphs in Blind Taste Test, Beating Premium Brands

Asda's Everyday Tea Bags outperform well-known brands in a Which? blind taste test, proving that quality doesn't always come with a high price tag. Experts praise its aroma, appearance, and flavor.

September 6 2024, 06:43 AM  •  1014 views

Asda's Budget Tea Triumphs in Blind Taste Test, Beating Premium Brands

In a surprising turn of events, Asda's Everyday Tea Bags have emerged victorious in a blind taste test conducted by consumer group Which?, outperforming renowned brands such as PG Tips, Tetley, and Twinings. This revelation challenges the notion that premium prices guarantee superior quality in the world of tea.

The taste test, involving 79 experienced tea enthusiasts, evaluated various aspects of each brew, including aroma, appearance, color, and flavor. Asda's budget-friendly offering scored an impressive 72%, with 68% of tasters deeming its color perfect and 49% finding the flavor ideal.

Image

Interestingly, the UK's tea-drinking habits have evolved over time. While the nation still consumes approximately 100 million cups daily, overall consumption has declined by 19% since 2010. Nevertheless, 84% of the British population remains devoted to this centuries-old tradition, which was first introduced to Britain in the 17th century.

Following closely behind Asda were PG Tips Original and Tetley Original, both scoring 71%. Tasters praised PG Tips for its ideal color, while Tetley received accolades for its pleasant mouthfeel and enticing aroma. It's worth noting that PG Tips, founded in 1930, was originally called Pre-Gestee Tea, reflecting its perceived digestive benefits.

Several other brands, including Sainsbury's Red Label, Aldi's Diplomat Red Label, Co-op's 99 Blend Fairtrade Tea, Waitrose Essential Original Blend, and Taylors of Harrogate Yorkshire Tea, all achieved respectable scores of 70% or 71%.

Surprisingly, Twinings Everyday and Tesco Original Tea tied for last place with 67%. Despite Twinings being the world's oldest tea company, established in 1706, its higher price point of £4.80 for 80 bags didn't translate to superior taste in this test.

"Our results show that the bigger and more expensive brands aren't necessarily the best for taste, with a supermarket own-brand costing less than 2p per cup emerging ahead of rivals costing up to four times as much."

Natalie Hitchins, Which? head of home products and services, commented:

This blind taste test not only highlights the quality of Asda's tea but also demonstrates the discerning palate of British tea drinkers. With the average Brit consuming 876 cups of tea per year, it's clear that the nation takes its brew seriously.

As tea continues to play a significant role in British culture, it's fascinating to reflect on its rich history. From the Boston Tea Party of 1773, which saw the destruction of 342 chests of tea, to the rationing of tea in the UK during World War II until 1952, this beloved beverage has been at the center of many historical events.

In conclusion, this taste test serves as a reminder that when it comes to tea, price doesn't always dictate quality. Whether you prefer a strong "builder's tea" or a delicate green tea (which accounts for only 3% of UK tea consumption), the perfect cup might just be more affordable than you think.