Antique Dealer Sues Over Aga Fire in Historic Oxfordshire Home
An antique dealer is taking legal action after an Aga oven fire caused extensive damage to his Grade II-listed property in Banbury, Oxfordshire. The incident resulted in significant losses and the death of a pet.
In a legal battle that highlights the intersection of historic preservation and modern appliance safety, an antique dealer is seeking compensation for a devastating fire that occurred in his Grade II-listed home. The incident, which took place approximately 5 years and 7 months ago in Banbury, Oxfordshire, resulted in nearly £620,000 in damages and the tragic loss of a beloved pet.
Alexander Cohane, 62, and his wife Andrea are pursuing legal action against M&N Heating & Plumbing and the insurance company Axa. The couple alleges that improper maintenance of their Aga cooker led to the fire that engulfed their seven-bedroom property during the early hours of February 20, 2019.
The historic significance of the Cohanes' residence adds a poignant layer to the case. The property was once home to Anne of Cleves, the fourth wife of King Henry VIII. This connection to Tudor history underscores the importance of preserving such architectural treasures.
The fire's impact on the Cohanes' antique business was substantial. Their stock, valued at £267,397, was largely destroyed, while personal possessions suffered damage amounting to approximately £351,000. As specialists in unique antiques, the couple faced not only financial losses but also the destruction of irreplaceable historical artifacts.
The legal dispute centers on the maintenance of the Aga cooker, an iconic British appliance. The Cohanes claim that M&N Heating & Plumbing, which serviced the Aga between 2016 and 2018, failed to properly maintain the appliance. Specifically, they allege that the company drained the boiler without replacing it with insulation, potentially contributing to the fire's outbreak.
The case has taken an additional turn due to the dissolution of M&N Heating & Plumbing in May 2021. This development has led the Cohanes to pursue Axa, which provided public liability insurance up to £5 million, for compensation.
"We were awakened in the early hours by smoke alarms and were forced to flee the property."
This incident serves as a stark reminder of the importance of proper appliance maintenance, especially in historic properties. Grade II listed buildings, which make up the majority of listed structures in England, require specialized care to preserve their architectural and historical integrity while ensuring modern safety standards are met.
As the legal proceedings unfold, this case may have broader implications for homeowners, antique dealers, and insurance providers alike. It underscores the delicate balance between preserving history and ensuring safety in our living spaces.
